Sara Crewe: whiny or wonderful?
Sequels to The Giver: valuable developments of Jonas's extended world or destroyers of the best ambiguous ending ever?
Dickens/Faulkner/Melville/insert name here: thoughtful or long-winded?
The best arguments are literary arguments. Do you have a favorite, a topic that gets you shaking your fist or waving underlined passages in people's faces? Post it here!